Pretty sure you're just pretending to be so naive at this point, Marianne.

I am certain this is a rhetoric question. Democrats need Manchin so badly to sabotage the alleged progressive agenda of the party so their filthy wealthy donors (sociopaths) who own the party can continue pouring money to their coffers.

Pull his chairmanship! Who cares if he switches teams. That's up for election in the fall anyway. Stand for something besides corporations and grifting.

The greatest senatorial role model since great Howard Baker with his "heathen devils"... Jesus Christ, I begin to miss Nixon and his Camorra enforcers

If I where a republican pretending to be a democrat I would be just like Joe.

Oil and Gas Industry want him there.

I K R!

The coddle him in order to keep him from going rogue and destroying the Democratic Agenda. It didn't work!!! 😠

Scott Pruitt same kind of distinction- historical exploitation