Around 1500s. Or when Calvinism caught on like the plague.

When Bill Clinton sold the DNC to Wall Street and threw working families under the bus.

When the government tried it.

Helping people who need help is a good thing. Extorting money from someone else in the name of helping people is a bad thing.

It's the violent insistence that you are forced according to some sociopaths vision of "help" that's the problem.

A: When gov't tried to be the social force to render "help" via forcible taxation & bureaucracy.

When our country decided Corporations were people

When someone is stealing from someone else to do it.

It’s prosperity doctrine. The Calvinist roots of American Protestantism and its focus on preordination as well.

Its not by all means go out and help people just don't send a gang of armed thugs after me to financially support you. I will help how and when I can. Its about choice and We are adults and can handle oir money way better than a government 27 trillion in debt obviously can