A true academic is someone who seeks the pure joy of discovering new knowledge and that joy is their earthly reward, regardless of what their peers think.

a really poor way to live a full life

Lots of aspirational definitions of an academic. What about some empirical research…? The hunting for grants, the jealousy, the burnt-out, the onhangers …, And why just academic idols? Managing complex programs deserves respect too. There is much great learning by doing.

Admirations? Are you sure? 😂

Surely that should read "criticism of their peers", no?

Then scholars are not academics.

😂

are you slightly conscious of what you wrote, Greg?

...and ended up with neither.

Play stupid games win stupid societal prizes