No-one is claiming absolute adherence to reality is the best solution.

noob

Sir, while no-one is criticising the realism of Real Life 1, the case could certainly be made that it is not balanced or polished to the extent one might expect from a Triple A title

In real life you could die instantly from a knife hit, or survive 20, which is far too random. Instead of calculating damage on 1 d800, they should do it with 200 d4, changing damage range from 1-800, to 200-800. Patching this in would improve melee.

This is me as I complain about map geometry not being smooth enough while tripping over uneven floors irl

Get critted, die shitted